Insufficient chill

also called Low chill, Chilling requirement not met

A fruit tree that grows well and never fruits. It needs a set number of cold hours in winter to break dormancy, and your winter is not cold enough for long enough.

Disorder Serious Doesn't spread

What you'll see

  • Buds opening late, unevenly and over a long straggling period rather than all together.
  • Many flower buds simply failing to open at all, and dropping off dry.
  • A thin, scattered blossom and almost no fruit set, on a tree that is otherwise vigorous.
  • Leaves emerging before or instead of the flowers, in the reverse of the normal order.
  • A tree that grows well, looks healthy and has never given a crop in the years you have had it.

Why it happens

Deciduous fruit trees count cold. They accumulate hours between roughly 0 and 7 °C through the winter, and until they reach the number their species and cultivar requires, the buds stay chemically locked. A tree needing 800 hours in a place that gives 400 will grow perfectly well and never come out of dormancy properly. Very warm spells in midwinter can even subtract from the total.

Mild-winter regions — the deep south, coastal California, the Gulf, and increasingly places that used to be cold enough. Also caused by planting a northern cultivar in a warm zone, or by a garden in an unusually mild urban heat island.

Treating it

  • There is no cure for a mismatched tree. Establish whether the chill requirement of the cultivar matches your area — the numbers are published.
  • Replace it with a low-chill cultivar if it does not; grafting a low-chill variety onto the existing rootstock is the quicker route.
  • Rule out the other causes of a non-fruiting tree first: no pollination partner, too much nitrogen, too much shade, frost on the open blossom, or simply a tree too young.
  • Dormancy-breaking sprays exist commercially and are not practical or worthwhile in a garden.
  • Site the tree where it gets the coldest air the garden has — a low, open, north-facing spot rather than a sheltered south wall.

Keeping it away

  • Look up your area average chill hours and buy cultivars rated at or below it. This is the whole of it.
  • Choose low-chill peaches, apples, plums and cherries, which are widely bred and readily available.
  • Buy from a regional nursery rather than a national catalogue; they stock what fruits locally.
  • Allow a margin, since chill hours are trending downward in most places.
  • Plant the tree in the coolest part of the garden rather than the warmest.

Who gets it

Apples, pears, peaches, cherries, plums, apricots, blueberries and currants — the deciduous fruits.